Armenia: judges Masis Melkonyan and Gevorg Poghosyan suspended as prosecution is cleared
- Published
- Updated
- Place
- Yerevan, Armenia
- Event date
- Past event —

Summary
Judges Masis Melkonyan and Gevorg Poghosyan have been suspended. On Saturday 14 November, Armenia’s Supreme Judicial Council authorised criminal proceedings against the two judges of Yerevan’s first-instance criminal court. It also suspended their powers until the proceedings are over. The decision, published that evening on the Council’s website, follows requests filed the day before by the acting Prosecutor General. It was taken behind closed doors after two sessions, on 13 and 14 November. The grounds have not been made public. According to the Armenian press, the two judges are suspected of abuse of power. Masis Melkonyan is known for having ordered the detention of several opposition and clergy figures. Authorisation to prosecute is not a conviction: both judges remain presumed innocent. Update, 15 November: prosecutors brought charges and imposed a ban on leaving on both judges.
On Saturday morning, prosecutors were still refusing to name them. They cited the secrecy of the investigation and “the authority of the judiciary”. The Council, for its part, said it did not give out information on Saturdays, according to Panorama.am. A few hours later, it nevertheless published its decision, naming both judges.
What the decision says
The text, quoted by NEWS.am, refers to motion No. 12-1384-26 from the acting Prosecutor General, dated 13 November. The Council consents to “public criminal prosecution” of Masis Melkonyan and Gevorg Poghosyan. Prosecutors had invoked Article 161 of the Judicial Code, according to Armenpress: without the Council’s consent, a judge cannot be prosecuted for acts linked to their duties. That safeguard has now been lifted.
The immediate consequence: the two judges can no longer sit. Their powers are suspended “until the end of the criminal proceedings”.
Two very different profiles
Masis Melkonyan is a familiar name. According to Azatutyun, as reported by AveNews and Aurora News, he ordered the detention of opposition MP Levon Kocharyan, General Tiran Khachatryan and two archbishops, Mikael Ajapahyan, head of the Shirak diocese, and Bagrat Galstanyan.
His name also came up in the case of Rustam Stepanyan, known as “Chagh Rustam”. The judge placed him under house arrest several times, before the appeals court sent him back to detention.
Gevorg Poghosyan keeps a lower profile. He was appointed a judge in 2021. He previously worked as a judge’s assistant, including at the Criminal Court of Appeal.
Update, 15 November: charges brought
On Sunday 15 November, the prosecutor general’s office took the next step. It brought criminal charges against the two judges, it told NEWS.am; Tert.am reported the same. Masis Melkonyan is charged with abuse or excess of authority. Gevorg Poghosyan is charged with complicity.
There is no detention at this stage: both judges are under a “ban on leaving”, a measure that prevents them from going away without permission. The newspaper Ishkhanutyun had mentioned a possible detention request. It has not happened so far. Neither judge has spoken publicly.
Analysis
The case is delicate for everyone. The government has for months been on the offensive against judges it accuses of dubious acquittals. The opposition, for its part, sees Masis Melkonyan as the man behind political detentions. Seeing him prosecuted may therefore please both camps, for opposite reasons. The key point remains: it is still unknown what exactly the two judges are accused of. Until the facts are set out, everyone can read their own story into it. Transparency will be the real test of this procedure.
Possible consequences
The two judges no longer sit and are now facing charges, under a ban on leaving. The reassignment of their pending cases remains to be seen.

